Melt Your Taste Buds With These Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches!

best cheeses for grilled cheese
Photo of author

By Abubaker Rafiq

Grilled cheese, a beloved comfort food staple, is a simple pleasure that brings warmth and nostalgia. The key to a well-made grilled cheese lies in the star ingredient – the best cheeses for grilled cheese! Join us on a delectable journey as we explore gourmet cheese that elevates the grilled cheese experience.

Discover the best cheese varieties for your favorite sandwiches and embark on a tasteful adventure!

Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Each cheese has its moment, and when it comes to grilled cheese, a few shine brightest. Let’s meet the distinguished five:


A classic choice that needs no introduction, cheddar’s firm texture and earthy, nutty flavor add a robust depth to your sandwich. Whether it’s sharp or mild, white or yellow, cheddar is a top pick for its superior melting ability and rich taste.


If sophistication is what you’re after, look no further. Gruyère, with its slightly sweet, slightly salty profile, and excellent melt, takes your grilled cheese from ordinary to extraordinary.

Dutch Cheese

Let’s not forget about the Dutch! The Netherlands is home to many cheeses, but when it comes to classic grilled cheese, Gouda and Edam take the cake. Both are semi-hard cheeses with a mild and buttery flavor that pairs perfectly with your choice of bread and toppings. Order Dutch cheeses here and taste the deliciousness for yourself.


Renowned for its stretchy, stringy effect, mozzarella introduces a delicate and milky flavor to a grilled cheese sandwich. It’s a subtle choice, perfectly complementing a variety of accompanying ingredients.


The epitome of creamy, brie brings a luxurious softness and earthy mushroom note to the sandwich. Melted brie is the epitome of indulgence, offering a soft, decadent texture that’s hard to resist.

Pepper Jack

For those who crave a kick, pepper jack is the answer. Infused with spices and a mild heat from jalapeños, pepper jack infuses a bold zing without overpowering the dish. It’s the cheese of choice for those who like a little adventure.

Pairing Cheeses with Additional Ingredients

A grilled cheese sandwich is like a canvas for culinary creativity. Pair your cheese with additional ingredients to create unique flavor profiles that cater to your mood or cravings.

Tomato and Cheddar

Cheddar and tomato are a match made in sandwich heaven. The acidity of tomatoes balances the richness of cheddar, creating a harmonious blend that tastes delightfully fresh.

Ham and Gruyère

Gruyère’s savory notes play exceptionally well with the saltiness of ham. This combination is a complete, well-rounded flavor experience that offers a bit of everything – salty, savory, and satisfyingly creamy.

Pesto and Mozzarella

Mozzarella’s neutral flavor complements the herbaceous, nutty tones of pesto. The combination is light and aromatic, perfect for those who prefer a more delicate palate.

Discovering the Best Cheeses for the Ultimate Grilled Cheese Experience

The journey through the best cheeses for grilled cheese offers a mere taste of the possibilities the grilled cheese sandwich can achieve. Experiment with these delicious combinations and have fun exploring pairings with your favorite ingredients.

Remember, the art of a great grilled cheese is both in the nuances of the cheese itself and the love you put into crafting it.

Happy grilling!

Browse our blog for more interesting reads like this.